Supporting Autonomy Without Losing Authority

ISSUE 2 | TERM 4 | 2025

Written by Dr Justin Coulson

Parenting involves a delicate balancing act: we want our children to grow into capable, independent decision-makers, but we also need to guide them with clarity, confidence, and care.

That’s where the great parenting challenge lies—supporting autonomy without losing authority.

Here are five practical, evidence-based principles that can help.

1. Set Clear, Calm, and Consistent Boundaries

Children thrive when they know where the boundaries are. Limits provide a sense of security and predictability. But boundaries are most effective when:

Children understand the reasons behind a request
Children feel that you see their perspective, and
Children are involved in solving problems or setting the boundaries themselves.

Then it’s up to us to ensure that:

They are communicated clearly.
They are upheld consistently.
They are enforced with calm and kindness.

When parents explain the “why” and invite their children to think through options with them, they foster understanding, empathy, and responsibility.

Tip: Avoid threats or emotional reactions. Instead, explain expectations ahead of time and follow through gently.

2. Set Up Consequences Through Shared Expectations

What we often call “natural consequences” are, in reality, imposed outcomes—like withholding screen time until homework is done. That’s not inherently wrong, but it must be set up collaboratively and communicated clearly ahead of time to avoid becoming punitive and creating relationship ruptures.

When limits are established through shared understanding—ideally as part of a conversation—they become a framework for accountability, not a punishment.

Important: Consequences should feel like a logical extension of the agreement—not an adult-imposed penalty.

3. Trust the Process of Internal Growth

When children feel supported by warm, autonomy-respecting parents, they are more likely to develop internal motivation over time. In one study, mothers who responded to their toddlers with patience and structure (see #1 above)—not control—fostered greater curiosity, persistence, and problem-solving skills in their children as they grew.

In other words, motivation isn’t something we install in our kids—it’s something they build when we trust them enough to allow it.

Encourage reflection and allow space for growth—even when it’s slow or messy.

4. Support Autonomy Through Choice and Voice

Autonomy support isn’t about giving kids a free pass or unlimited choice. It’s about helping them take the wheel with our helpful, supportive navigation from the passenger seat when they get a little lost or need direction. This includes:

Encouraging reflection rather than issuing orders. “How did that go for you?”
Valuing their voice: “How do you think that worked out?” or “What do you think would help next time?”

By focusing on open-ended questions and meaningful dialogue, we move away from control and towards partnership. Children who feel respected are more likely to engage thoughtfully, cooperate, and take ownership of their actions. When children feel ownership over their choices, their motivation and cooperation increase.

5. Don’t Give Up When It Gets Tough

Consistency doesn’t mean rigidity. But when we hold our boundaries with calm resolve—especially when it’s hard—we send a powerful message: “I believe in you. I believe you can do hard things.” It also says, “We have values and standards in this family. You know them. You helped create them. I believe you can live them.”

Growth takes time. But repeated, respectful reinforcement builds the skills and self-trust our kids need to thrive.

Parenting is a long game. Don’t give up because it’s tough. Stay steady because it matters.

Working with our children is always more effective than doing things to them. Autonomy and authority are not opposites—they’re partners. Children flourish when they are given space to grow, paired with firm but compassionate guidance.

Yes, rules are important. But so is trust. And when children feel understood, supported, and believed in, they are far more likely to rise to the challenge.

Prep N	Elena Khouzi Zachariah Pham
1/2 M	Emi Deprez
1/2 S	No award due to Incursion
1/2 V	Remi Wohling Michael Abboud
3/4 F	Greta Brown
3/4 K	Finlay Abang
3/4 P	Sarah Hart
5/6 L	Edward Hollis
5/6 N	Shreyan Chatterjee
5/6 R	Jay Zaydan

Awards and Celebrations

BIRTHDAYS

October