Banner Photo

Debating

Our team of four Year 8s began debating in August. Our actual debates didn’t begin until September, but before that we were tasked with the challenge of figuring out how we could actually participate in debating as well as preparing for the debates. Our wonderful crew began with a loss in our first debate against Camberwell High, with Tengyi achieving best speaker. Later, we redeemed ourselves in our final two debates against Salesian College (Chadstone), where Gabby was best speaker, and Camberwell Grammar (which was the hosting school) where Tengyi was again best speaker. It was a really great experience that helped us all build new skills as well as further develop others, while being able to have fun doing it. But to really get a better idea of the experience, let's ask our debaters:

 

Gabby: I had a great experience debating this year. I am so proud of all of us for completing all 3 debates. I had only done one debate before this year’s debates, so this gave me the chance to hone the basic skills I learned last year and put the feedback I got into practice. I truly learnt a lot and had so much fun doing so. Through all the highs and lows, debating in its core was so great to be a part of. We made lots of memories together with lots of afterschool trips to the library and Yobar and with other friends helping us along the way. Thank you so much to Miss Oliver for taking the time to organise this for us and come with us on the four nights we went to Camberwell Grammar.

 

Rhea: This year being in debating was an amazing journey. In the past few months, we’ve learnt much more than just debating skills. While Miss Oliver was always there to support us, and made debating possible (thank you so much!!!), we, the students, organised meetups, and initiated first contact with the organisation ourselves. We kept each other motivated and collaborated. Being part of debating really helped me learn teamwork and independence (that sounds a bit like an oxymoron, but it’s true. Independence in the sense of not completely relying on adults to organise everything). This experience made completing each debate, even the one that we lost, feel so rewarding; just seeing all the work we put in pay off. 

 

Thet: This year was my first time speaking in debates, since I would normally just watch the process from the audience. It was a bit of an adjustment going from watching them to being a part of planning them, but I found it a lot of fun and actually a good way to improve my public speaking skills. I'm less of a social person, and coming up and speaking in front of multiple people as well as being graded for it made me feel nervous at first, because everything mattered and meant something. In the end, I'm really proud of myself for doing so well and winning my first debates, and my teammates, who all worked hard and righteously earned the wins. Debating did not turn out to be what I expected it to be but I'm glad I chose to do it. 

 

Tengyi: As someone who has done debating for quite a while, it was still quite fascinating to represent Glen Eira College in this event. Although I was already familiar with some of the basics of debating, this experience allowed me to further develop my skills, particularly in constructing stronger arguments, delivering rebuttals, constructing models and working together with my teammates. What made this experience especially enjoyable was being able to share my passion of debating with others and watch us grow together as a team. Winning two out of our three debates was certainly a rewarding achievement, but I believe the most valuable part in this event was the opportunity to learn from each debate, support one another, and represent our school with pride. I am incredibly grateful to Miss Oliver for making this experience possible, and I truly believe that everyone should have a go at debating!

 

Miss Oliver: Congratulations to Gabby, Rhea, Thet and Tengyi for their diligent preparation and excellent arguments, which saw them win 2/3 debates! I was even more impressed by their outstanding sportsmanship shown throughout the whole tournament. They represented Glen Eira College so well, and they should all be very proud!

 

Before we wrap this up, we want to give a special shout out to Miss Oliver, who stepped up by helping to organise the debates as well as accompanying us there, when no one else would. Overall, debating this year was a really fun, amazing yet educational experience that I am sure we will all cherish for years to come.

 

Gabby Lim

Year 8