Debating News

Strathmore Secondary College narrowly defeated in Semi-Final.
On Thursday the 8th of October, the Strathmore Secondary College 1 (Year12) debate team, comprising Joseph Price, Andreas Oltoumis, and Joseph Thorsen, competed in the A grade DAV semi-finals against Melbourne Grammar. The venue for this debate was situated at the picturesque Korowa Girls Anglican College, in Glen Iris. The Strathmore team had been successful against Suzanne Corey, St. Joseph’s College from Geelong, and Xavier College from Kew before reaching the semi-final against Melbourne Grammar.
Although the Strathmore team was defeated by Melbourne Grammar, the ultimate adjudication was the result of a split decision between a panel of three adjudicators. As it transpired, one adjudicator awarded the win to Strathmore, while the other two adjudicators awarded the decision to Melbourne Grammar. The secret topic was provided to the teams one hour before the debate began. No iPhones or iPads were permitted, and the debaters were locked away for an hour to create a case, supported by a set of arguments, and to discuss and define the terms of the proposition.
The topic itself, 'That we should seek to break up Australia's oligopolies,’ was cleverly chosen and provided ample opportunity for both sides to produce a well organised case, as well as rebut each other’s case. Strathmore Secondary College was assigned the negative side and so, in the face of rather skilled opposition, provided a very formidable fight (hence the split decision). The standard of the rebuttal by both sides was extremely high; it was incisive, extended and attacking in manner, and reflected the strong listening skills of all speakers. Listening intently and thinking effectively on the spot, are essential skills for any debater.
The Strathmore Secondary College 1 result is unprecedented in Strathmore debating history, despite not winning the debate itself, as no Strathmore team has ever progressed to the semi-finals before. It was a truly commendable effort, and one that Strathmore takes great pride in. Well done team!
Mr. C. Bassios.
Debating and Public Speaking Coordinator.













